Thanksgiving illustration: after dinner, a man in a floral apron washes the dishes while a woman toasts him with Bella Principessa Prosecco, the gold and pink bottles on the counter and football on TV in the next room

What to Bring to Thanksgiving Dinner as a Guest, and the Other Unwritten Rules

What to bring to Thanksgiving dinner as a guest, what wine to bring, when to arrive, where to sit and how to leave. The unwritten rules, written down by a guest.

Michael GoldsteinFounder, Bella Principessa · 15 min read

Cover illustration, for illustration purposes.

In this story 15 parts
  1. Thanksgiving etiquette for guests
  2. The other side of the door
  3. What wine to bring to Thanksgiving
  4. What to bring to Thanksgiving dinner as a guest
  5. Thanksgiving etiquette for hosts
  6. The adopted guest, on screen
  7. What Italy would add to the table
  8. Thanksgiving by the numbers
  9. How much Prosecco for Thanksgiving
  10. Friendsgiving
  11. Where to buy Bella Principessa
  12. The last bottle
  13. About the author
  14. For journalists
  15. Thanksgiving etiquette questions

I am not American. For years I spent Thanksgiving in America anyway, at other families’ tables in Miami and Los Angeles, a long way from my own. Every table seems to have one guest from somewhere else. I was it: the token European.

You know how it works. A friend decides you can’t possibly be on your own on Thursday, and by the afternoon you have been adopted. It is a generous American custom. When YouGov asked in 2013, 66% of Southerners said they invite people to Thanksgiving who would otherwise be alone.

I was grateful every time. But the foreigner arrives with no childhood Thanksgivings to steer by. Everyone else has done this thirty times. You are learning it live: which chair is Grandpa’s, when to stand up for the football, why nobody leaves before pie. Six hours on your best behavior, in a house where everyone else gets to be themselves.

Nobody writes the rules down. So here they are, from the guest who had to learn them from scratch.

The first one is decided before you ring the bell: what’s in your hands.

Michael Goldstein is the founder of Bella Principessa, which is mentioned in this article.

The short version

  • What to bring to Thanksgiving dinner as a guest: a bottle. Bring it cold if you want it opened, warm with a note if it is a hostess gift. Arrive on time, never early.
  • Plan dinner for about 4 p.m. Eastern, between the 1 p.m. and 4:30 p.m. NFL games.
  • Pour before grace, so the toast follows the blessing.
  • A 750 ml bottle of Prosecco pours five 5-ounce glasses. Ten guests need 4 bottles for brunch, 6 for a party.
  • Chill one more bottle than you need.

Thanksgiving etiquette for guests: the unwritten rules

1. “Come around two” means 2:00 for the guest.
Family can drift in whenever they like. The guest arrives on time, and never early. Early means you are standing in the kitchen while someone is basting.

2. The kitchen has a ruler.
Offer to help once. If the answer is no, believe it. Then clear the plates after dinner without asking.

3. Never sit until you are shown a chair.
Somebody has sat in that seat since 1987.

4. A warm bottle is a gift. A cold bottle is a drink.
Hand the host a bottle at room temperature and one of two things happens. It goes into a fridge that was full by Wednesday, or she says “Oh, that’s so pretty, I’ll save it,” and puts it somewhere safe. You won’t see it again today. Hand her a cold one and it’s open before your coat is off.

I’ve watched it happen with Bella Principessa more than once. The bottle is too pretty to open, so it goes on a shelf. If you want it poured, bring it cold. If you want it remembered, bring it warm.

“I’ve watched it happen with Bella Principessa Prosecco. Bring it warm and it goes in the fridge or on a shelf for another day. Bring it cold and it’s open before your coat is off.”

5. The fridge is full by Wednesday.
By Thursday the bottles are in the garage, in a cooler, or in the bathtub. Arrive with yours already cold: 30 minutes in a bucket of ice and water before you leave, then an insulated bag for the drive.

6. The gratitude round reaches the guest.
It will come to you, and everyone will turn to look. Keep it short and thank the host by name. Everyone else at the table is related. You are the only one who chose to be there.

7. Seconds are a compliment.
Take a little of everything the first time, so there is room for more.

8. The game is not background noise.
Never ask who is winning during a play. If you don’t follow football, follow the people who do: when they stand up, stand up.

9. The goodbye takes 45 minutes.
“We should get going” is only the opening line. Begin leaving half an hour before you need to go.

10. You leave with foil.
Take the leftovers. It is your adoption certificate.

The other side of the door

I have also been the host. For years I gave dinner parties, long before I was in the Prosecco business, and the invitation carried one dress code: champagne and Louboutins.

The guests who knew the house arrived with $60 and $100 bottles. They went on ice on the kitchen counter and we opened them as the evening went on. It was a dinner party, not a keg party. Nobody came to get drunk. We came to be merry. The Italians call it convivialità.

The guests who didn’t know the house went to the liquor store, where the cheapest Prosecco can sit right beside the Champagne, and came back with a $12 bottle with a paper label nobody had heard of. To them it was champagne. Nobody had ever told them otherwise.

My girlfriend at the time would look at it and say, quietly, “I’m not serving that.” We thanked them, warmly and meaning it, and the bottle never made it to the counter. Snobbish? A little. Wine has a snob appeal, and however gracious you are, you can’t get around it.

The problem was never Prosecco. It was a bottle that said nobody had thought about it. Those bottles are one of the reasons I shaped how Bella Principessa looks: the painted bottle, no paper label, Happier Ever After on the side.

What wine to bring to Thanksgiving: why Prosecco

Most guests bring one of three things: flowers, a pie or a bottle. Flowers need a vase at the busiest hour of the host’s day. A pie competes with hers. A bottle is the one gift she can open now or keep for later.

And of all the bottles, sparkling wine is the one that becomes part of the day: the aperitivo when everyone arrives, the toast after grace, a glass with the turkey and the cranberry. Americans call all of it champagne. Prosecco wine is how Italy does it: the bubbles without the $60 statement, so you can bring two.

So is Prosecco good for Thanksgiving? It works from the doorbell to the turkey. The dish-by-dish pairings are in Prosecco for Thanksgiving.

What to bring to Thanksgiving dinner as a guest: what your bottle says about you

Which leaves one question: which bottle. Because the bottle you choose says what you think of her table, and what you think of yourself.

Every guest gets judged on one thing before the coat comes off: the bottle. Most of us have brought at least one of these.

The paper label nobody has heard of. Picked up on the way for about ten dollars. It says: I passed a store.

The cheapest acceptable bottle. Not the cheapest. The one just above it, so nobody could call it cheap. It says: I did the arithmetic.

The bottle with the price sticker still on. It says exactly what it cost, and nothing else.

The bottle in the plastic bag. It says the bag was free.

The bottle somebody gave you last year. It says nothing at all, until the host recognizes it.

And then there is the bottle that says: I thought about this.

The aisle

It’s Wednesday night, you’re in the wine aisle, and the host said she likes Prosecco. That narrows it down to a wall. You are not spending $60 on Champagne. You are also not walking in with the bottle that looks like it came free with the turkey. So the price becomes your guide, because nothing else is. Green glass, paper label, a name you’ll have forgotten by the time you reach the car.

That is the guesswork Bella Principessa Prosecco DOC was made to take away. You see it from the end of the aisle: ceramic-painted, Italian flowers and butterflies, no paper label. It looks like you spent more than you did. Inside, it is Prosecco DOC wine from a fourth-generation Italian winery. The bottle looks beautiful. The wine lives up to it.

The suggested retail price is $20.99, and holiday specials may bring the shelf price lower. If you want to be a mensch, pick up two, the gold and the pink, for about $40: one to toast, one to give. In Florida this season you may find the Bella Principessa team pouring it in store on weekends. Everywhere else, you can order it online.

Which one to bring

Bella Principessa Prosecco DOC on a candlelit Thanksgiving table with glasses of sparkling wine and pumpkin pieBella Principessa Prosecco DOC Rosé on a candlelit Thanksgiving table with glasses of pink sparkling wine and cranberry sauce
The gold and the pink: Bella Principessa Prosecco DOC and Prosecco DOC Rosé.
  • Bella Principessa Prosecco DOC, the gold bottle, for the classic Thanksgiving: the aperitivo, the toast after grace, and the turkey.
  • Bella Principessa Prosecco DOC Rosé, the pink one, for the cranberry sauce, the Friendsgiving brunch, and the host who has never once turned down pink.
  • Both, if you want to be invited back.
  • Both, definitely, if you are meeting her parents for the first time. Her mother will read Happier Ever After on the bottle. Let her.

Thanksgiving etiquette for hosts

Give the adopted guest a job.
The kindest thing you can do for a guest who knows nobody is hand them the bottle to open and pour. They have something to do with their hands, you have one less job, and the bottle they brought gets poured.

Thanksgiving table ideas: dress the table before the turkey.
People taste with their eyes first. French researchers dyed a white wine red, and 54 tasters described it as a red. At Caltech, people enjoyed the same wine more when they were told it cost more. At Oxford, researchers found heavier wine bottles tend to carry higher prices, and shoppers read the weight as quality. So press the tablecloth, keep the candles low enough to see faces, use real glasses, and put the bottles on the table instead of hiding them in the kitchen. A good-looking bottle is decor you can pour.

Plan dinner around the game.
Serve at 1 p.m. and the turkey competes with the Lions. The turkey loses. Have guests arrive during the 1 p.m. game, sit down when it ends, around 4 p.m. Eastern, and serve dessert at halftime of the 4:30 game.

Pour before grace.
Nothing interrupts a blessing like a cork. Every glass should be full before anyone sits, so the toast can follow the last word.

Count drinkers, not invitations.
Leave out designated drivers and anyone under 21, and put good non-alcoholic drinks on the table too.

Chill one more bottle than you need.
Nobody remembers the turkey was dry. Everybody remembers the bubbles ran out.

The adopted guest, on screen

For most of the world, Thanksgiving is something you see on screen long before you see it on a table. Hollywood has been making the same film for forty years: somebody ends up at a table that isn’t theirs, and the family turns out to be stranger than the guest.

Planes, Trains and Automobiles (1987)

Steve Martin needs to get from New York to Chicago for Thanksgiving. It takes him three days, a burnt-out rental car and a motel bed shared with Del, a shower-curtain-ring salesman played by John Candy. At the very end he works out that Del, who has ruined every one of those days, has nowhere to go. So he takes him home.

That is how adoption works. Nobody adopts you because you’re good company. They adopt you because they did the arithmetic on you being alone on Thursday and couldn’t live with the answer. Del turns up with a steamer trunk and nothing for the host. He gets away with it because he’s John Candy. You are not John Candy. Bring a bottle.

The most famous adopted guest in American film gets his invitation.

Seinfeld, “The Mom & Pop Store” (1994)

Jerry hears about a Thanksgiving party and spends the episode trying to work out whether he’s actually invited. Every adopted guest has been Jerry. “You should come” from the host’s cousin is not an invitation. It’s a rumor.

The fix is one text to the host, and it isn’t “Am I invited?” It’s “What can I bring?” “Just yourself” means you’re in. Silence means you’re watching the parade at home.

Jerry, still not sure he’s invited.

Friends (1994 to 2004)

Almost every season has a Thanksgiving episode, and Monica cooks nearly all of them. Look at that table: six adults with families, and not one of them at home with theirs. It is an orphans’ Thanksgiving in a better apartment than any orphan has ever had. And Monica spends ten years cooking for people who arrive late, argue in her kitchen and leave with her leftovers. Anyone who has hosted knows exactly what her face is doing.

Season one, 1994: the first Friends Thanksgiving.

Two more worth a rewatch: Jodie Foster’s Home for the Holidays (1995), and Gilmore Girls, “A Deep-Fried Korean Thanksgiving” (2002), in which Lorelai and Rory accept four invitations for the same day.

Now try to remember the bottle anyone brought in any of these. Neither can we. On screen the guest brings the drama. At a real table, the host would rather have the bottle.

What Italy would add to the table

An Italian hears about Thanksgiving and nods. Italy has a version every Sunday: the grandmother who won’t sit down, the uncle with opinions, the argument about the food that is really about something else. Italy would bring four things to yours.

  • L’aperitivo. Something cold and something salty while everyone arrives. In Italy, nobody goes straight from the front door to the table.
  • La bella figura. The art of making a good impression. Dress one level above whatever was asked, and the host is dressed before the first guest rings the bell. Elastic waistbands are a dessert decision, not an arrival decision.
  • Il brindisi. The toast, with every glass already full.
  • La passeggiata. A short walk after dinner, before the pie.

You bring the turkey, the football and the gratitude. Italy brings the aperitivo, the bubbles and the bella figura. That is la dolce vita, with pie.

Thanksgiving by the numbers

Americans sit in traffic on I-95, sleep on air mattresses in childhood bedrooms and fly through Atlanta the day before a holiday, on purpose. All of it for one meal. Here is the day in figures, for readers and for journalists.

Thanksgiving in figures The figures in this article, with their sources
Figure What it measures Source
81.8 million Americans projected to travel 50 miles or more over the holiday, a record AAA, 2025
78% View Thanksgiving positively, the highest of any U.S. holiday (Christmas: 76%) YouGov
65% Say someone at their table says a blessing Pew, 2024
69% Say someone shares what they are thankful for Pew, 2024
66% Southerners who invite people who would otherwise be alone YouGov, 2013
3 NFL games on Thanksgiving Day: 1 p.m., 4:30 p.m. and 8:20 p.m. Eastern FOX Sports, 2026

Nine in ten Americans celebrate

91% of Americans celebrate Thanksgiving, and 74% planned to have dinner with other people, which is how so many of those other people end up being guests.

Source: Pew Research Center, November 2024.

When America wants dinner

The country splits almost evenly between an early and a late afternoon dinner.

Source: Pew Research Center, November 2024; FOX Sports, 2026 NFL schedule.

How much Prosecco for Thanksgiving

A 750 ml bottle pours five 5-ounce glasses, or six shorter 4-ounce pours for a toast. For 10 guests, that is 2 bottles for a toast, 4 for brunch and 6 for a party. Guides that promise six glasses a bottle are counting the smaller pour, and that is exactly where hosts run out. Serve at 43 to 46°F.

For pairings dish by dish and bottle counts up to 100 guests, see Prosecco for Thanksgiving: what to pour, with what, and how much. For your own numbers, use the drinks calculator. For the drinks themselves, see six Thanksgiving Prosecco cocktails. And if someone at the table wants to know how Prosecco differs from champagne, The Brut Truth has it.

Friendsgiving: the dress rehearsal

Friendsgiving is Thanksgiving with the people who chose each other. It usually happens the weekend before the real thing, which this year means November 21 and 22. Nobody is adopted, because everybody is.

Before anyone said Friendsgiving, people called it an orphans’ Thanksgiving. Merriam-Webster traces the word to 2007, and one early printed use came from the Pensacola News Journal in 2008, inviting readers who open their feasts to “holiday orphans.” The dictionary added it in 2020.

Use a shared sign-up sheet. Without one, three people bring mac and cheese and nobody brings dessert. Host it as a brunch and the Rosé suits the morning light. For what to bring, see What to Bring to Friendsgiving.

Where to buy Bella Principessa

Order online. ProseccoWine.com ships cases of 6 or 12 to 43 states. It is run by a separate licensed retailer.

In Florida. Total Wine & More and Luekens Wine & Spirits carry Bella Principessa, along with independent stores across the state. Both chains take orders online for local delivery. Find a store near you.

Please enjoy responsibly. Guests must be 21 or over, and everyone needs a safe way home.

The last bottle

By nine o’clock the game is over, the dishwasher is on its second load, and somebody is asleep on the sofa with a plate on his chest. The host finally sits down. There is one bottle left in the fridge, the pink one, because she chilled one extra. She pours two glasses: one for herself, and one for whoever stayed to help clear. Often, it’s the foreigner.

About the author

Michael Goldstein is the founder and creative director of Bella Principessa Prosecco DOC, sold in Florida stores and online. A European, he has spent Thanksgiving as the adopted guest at American tables in Miami and Los Angeles, and years hosting dinner parties of his own.

For journalists

The rules, figures and quotes in this article may be used with credit to Michael Goldstein, founder of Bella Principessa. The figures are in the table above, with their sources. High-resolution images, interviews and samples are available on request from the press office: press@prosecco.com.

Thanksgiving etiquette questions

What should I bring to Thanksgiving dinner as a guest?
Ask the host. If the answer is nothing, bring a bottle anyway: cold if you want it opened that day, or at room temperature with a note if it is a hostess gift for later.

What wine should I bring to Thanksgiving dinner?
Something that looks chosen. A Brut Prosecco wine works from the aperitivo to the turkey. Bring it cold to open, or warm with a note to keep.

What is a good hostess gift for Thanksgiving dinner?
Something the host can enjoy after everyone leaves: a bottle that looks like a gift, flowers already in a vase, or something for the home.

What time should I arrive for Thanksgiving dinner?
At the time you were given, and never early.

What time should Thanksgiving dinner be?
Most Americans prefer the afternoon. In 2026, around 4 p.m. Eastern sits between the 1 p.m. and 4:30 p.m. NFL games.

How do I chill Prosecco fast for Thanksgiving?
Thirty minutes in a bucket of ice and water. The fridge takes about three hours. Serve at 43 to 46°F.

How many glasses in a bottle of Prosecco?
Five 5-ounce glasses, or six shorter 4-ounce pours.

What to wear to Thanksgiving dinner?
Ask the host. With no dress code, wear dinner clothes, one level up from what you think is expected.

When is Friendsgiving in 2026?
Usually the weekend before Thanksgiving: November 21 and 22.

Is Prosecco the same as champagne?
No. Prosecco is Italian sparkling wine and Champagne is French. In America, “champagne” is often used for both.

Is Prosecco good for Thanksgiving?
Yes. A Brut Prosecco wine works as the aperitivo when guests arrive, the toast after grace, and a glass with the turkey and cranberry. For dish-by-dish pairings, see Prosecco for Thanksgiving.

What should I bring to Thanksgiving dinner with my boyfriend’s family?
Two bottles: one cold to open when you arrive, and one warm, with a note, for the host to keep. A Brut and a Rosé cover both, and give his mother something to read.

Sources


Keep this story

Print it, save it, or send it to the friend who’s hosting.

Michael Goldstein, founder of Bella Principessa

Written by

Michael Goldstein

Founder and Creative Director, Bella Principessa

He believes the best introductions happen over a glass, and that time with family and friends, old and new, is the real luxury. He writes here about the brand and the people who share it.

Read his story →

Share a moment.
One sip at a time.
Made in Italy.

Bella Principessa Prosecco DOC on a blue butterfly card Bella Principessa Prosecco DOC Rosé on a pink butterfly card

Ships to 43 states.